| |
Main
Date: 24 Oct 2006 00:18:39
From: Garrison Hilliard
Subject: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
From staff and wire reports
Associated Press
Silver carp, like this one in the Missouri River, were brought to the United
States from Asia about 30 years ago.
ST. LOUIS - For years, boaters and fishermen on many midwestern rivers have
battled a fish with a bizarre behavior: silver carp that launch themselves into
the air, jumping into boats and often slapping the unsuspecting upside the head.
"They can break your nose or knock you out of the boat," said Duane Chapman, a
fisheries biologist with the U.S. Geological Survey.
The carp, brought to the United States from Asia by private fish farmers 30
years ago, are more than a nuisance to people. They and their non-jumping
relative, the bighead carp, compete with native fish for food such as
paddlefish, bigmouth buffalo and gizzard shad.
They have established themselves in parts of the Missouri, Mississippi, Ohio and
Illinois rivers.
Silver carp are rare in the Cincinnati area of the Ohio River, according to
biologists with the Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission.
"They're pretty abundant in the lower part of the river around Paducah, but
they're not common up here," said biologist Jeff Thomas. "We did see one last
year around the Markland Dam. Other than that, I haven't heard any reports of
them around Cincinnati."
However, that could change in a few years.
"They seem to be gradually working their way upstream," said Thomas. "If water
conditions are right for them up here, we may see them in a couple of years."
Thomas said the river temperature is cooler and the water is clearer in the
Cincinnati area than it is down river.
"We're not really sure which factors are most critical for silver carp," said
Erich Emery, another ORSANCO biologist. "Only time will tell if the conditions
here are conducive to them. They do seem to like to breed in sluggish, backwater
areas and there are more of those areas down river than here."
There's little profit for commercial fishermen in harvesting the fish. But the
St. Louis Zoo may be the answer to that dilemma.
Rob Hayward, a University of Missouri-Columbia fisheries researcher, and Chapman
are part of a team of researchers seeking to create a carp product to feed to
zoo animals.
"We want to make good food of bad fish," said Ellen Dierenfeld, staff
nutritionist at the zoo.
The zoo, one of the nation's largest, annually purchases as feed more than 60
tons of fish - mostly marine species such as mackerel, herring and capelin.
Prices range from 30 cents to 70 cents per pound, and zoo officials believe they
could save money by feeding the carp to animals.
Dierenfeld believes up to 25 percent of the fish feed could be replaced with
carp.
"This would help reduce pressures on marine fisheries and help solve the Asian
carp problem," she said.
And if the more than 200 accredited U.S. zoos did likewise, commercial fishermen
would have a reason to harvest the nuisance fish.
University of Missouri-Columbia food scientist Andrew Clarke has developed a
"carp cake" made from raw, ground fish, a process that allows different size
feed for different animals. Dierenfeld said vitamins and mineral supplements
could be added to the carp cake.
Dierenfeld hopes to begin a pilot feeding study with penguins, sea lions and
pelicans by next spring. Other zoos may also participate, she said.
The Cincinnati Zoo is not currently a candidate for the program.
"We've heard of it, but we have no plans for it at this time," said Cincinnati
Zoo spokeswoman Barbara Risch..
Asian carp were imported in the 1970s as a way to control algae and plankton in
fish ponds. But during the floods of 1993 and 1995, the fish made their way into
the wild.
It is believed the silver carp jump out of the water as a flight response when
disturbed - possibly by the sound of boat motors.
The high-jumping fish can be so dangerous that Missouri Department of
Conservation staff wear head gear for protection while motoring on fast-moving
boats. Some state boats have protective netting around the driver area and
across the bow.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service last month published a proposed rule to ban
the import and interstate transport of silver carp.
Publication date: 10-23-2006
http://news.cincypost.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20061023/NEWS01/610230363
|
|
| |
Date: 01 Nov 2006 11:12:23
From: garrison@efn.org
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
(PeteCresswell) wrote:
> Per garrison@efn.org:
> >Did it look like this?
> >
> >http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4627225444978786151&q=carp+jumping&hl=en
>
> Are these things the same as "Snakeheads"?
No, that's a totally different invasive species of fish, a
sharp-toothed predator something like a pike..
|
| |
Date: 01 Nov 2006 06:12:25
From: garrison@efn.org
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Tracy C wrote:
> Saw this on the news - was unbelievable! The fish were jumping all over the
> place - some folks got hit in the face, with at least one person getting a
> broken nose. Lots of people wore goggles to protect their eyes. Couldn't
> believe what I was seeing! As soon as they started the boats, fish were
> jumping everywhere. Was fun to watch.
Did it look like this?
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4627225444978786151&q=carp+jumping&hl=en
|
| | |
Date: 01 Nov 2006 12:58:59
From: (PeteCresswell)
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Per garrison@efn.org:
>Did it look like this?
>
>http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4627225444978786151&q=carp+jumping&hl=en
Are these things the same as "Snakeheads"?
--
PeteCresswell
|
| | | |
Date: 02 Nov 2006 21:06:42
From: riverman
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
"(PeteCresswell)" <x@y.Invalid > wrote in message
news:j2ohk2dlh4booju558rg4n20756r94cqop@4ax.com...
> Per garrison@efn.org:
>>Did it look like this?
>>
>>http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4627225444978786151&q=carp+jumping&hl=en
>
> Are these things the same as "Snakeheads"?
> --
No. Here's a picture of a snakehead
http://www.dgif.state.va.us/fishing/snakehead_comparisons.pdf
and here's some carp
http://www.cerc.usgs.gov/pubs/center/pdfDocs/Asian_carp-2-2004.pdf
Both are invasive species from China, and both are devistating to local
fisheries. But wow, would I like to get a snakehead on a 4wt fly rod... :-)
--riverman
|
| | | | |
Date: 02 Nov 2006 09:46:06
From: Bill Tuthill
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
riverman <nospam@sorry.com > wrote:
>
> Here's a picture of a snakehead
> http://www.dgif.state.va.us/fishing/snakehead_comparisons.pdf
>
> and here's some carp
> http://www.cerc.usgs.gov/pubs/center/pdfDocs/Asian_carp-2-2004.pdf
>
> Both are invasive species from China, and both are devistating to local
> fisheries. But wow, would I like to get a snakehead on a 4wt fly rod... :-)
Is snakehead good to eat?
|
| | | | | |
Date: 03 Nov 2006 03:04:38
From: riverman
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
"Bill Tuthill" <ccreekin@yahoo.com > wrote in message
news:454a2ede@news.meer.net...
> riverman <nospam@sorry.com> wrote:
>>
>> Here's a picture of a snakehead
>> http://www.dgif.state.va.us/fishing/snakehead_comparisons.pdf
>>
>> and here's some carp
>> http://www.cerc.usgs.gov/pubs/center/pdfDocs/Asian_carp-2-2004.pdf
>>
>> Both are invasive species from China, and both are devistating to local
>> fisheries. But wow, would I like to get a snakehead on a 4wt fly rod...
>> :-)
>
> Is snakehead good to eat?
>
Oh yes. In this part of the world (China), its a delicacy. But that's not
what I'm interested in...any fish that grows to be 15 pounds or more, with
all those teeth, and that fights as hard as these guys do would be a blast
to catch on a small rod.
In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US might be
to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting them on menus.
Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
--riverman
|
| | | | | | |
Date: 02 Nov 2006 14:32:01
From: (PeteCresswell)
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Per riverman:
>In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US might be
>to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting them on menus.
>Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
First thing, somebody's got to come up with
a sweeter-sounding name than "snakehead"..... -)
--
PeteCresswell
|
| | | | | | | |
Date: 02 Nov 2006 17:54:58
From: Bill Tuthill
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Pete Cresswell <x@y.invalid > wrote:
>
> Per riverman:
>>In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US might be
>>to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting them on menus.
>>Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
>
> First thing, somebody's got to come up with
> a sweeter-sounding name than "snakehead"..... -)
The Latin name is Channa (marulius, micropeltes, lucius, striata, gachua).
That sounds pretty good! Reminds me of Chana Masala. Picture here:
http://www.pattayafishing.com/freshwater.html
|
| | | | | | | | |
Date: 03 Nov 2006 21:20:47
From: riverman
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
"Bill Tuthill" <ccreekin@yahoo.com > wrote in message
news:454aa172@news.meer.net...
> Pete Cresswell <x@y.invalid> wrote:
>>
>> Per riverman:
>>>In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US might
>>>be
>>>to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting them on
>>>menus.
>>>Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
>>
>> First thing, somebody's got to come up with
>> a sweeter-sounding name than "snakehead"..... -)
>
> The Latin name is Channa (marulius, micropeltes, lucius, striata, gachua).
> That sounds pretty good! Reminds me of Chana Masala. Picture here:
>
> http://www.pattayafishing.com/freshwater.html
>
Ugh, I hate that site. I've seen it before.....the picture of the Giant
Mekong Catfish bugs the hell out of me. Those are incredibly old, incredibly
rare and incredibly at-risk fish, and its a crime that Pattaya Fishing
advertises that they will take you fishing for them.
That picture is of the largest freshwater fish ever caught and recorded.
Here's a story about the efforts to save these fish:
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/05/0515_030515_giantcatfish.html
--riverman
|
| | | | | | | | | |
Date: 04 Nov 2006 21:39:47
From: John Fereira
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
"riverman" <nospam@sorry.com > wrote in news:454b422c$1@127.0.0.1:
>
> "Bill Tuthill" <ccreekin@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:454aa172@news.meer.net...
>> Pete Cresswell <x@y.invalid> wrote:
>>>
>>> Per riverman:
>>>>In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US
>>>>might be to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting
>>>>them on menus. Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
>>>
>>> First thing, somebody's got to come up with a sweeter-sounding name
>>> than "snakehead"..... -)
>>
>> The Latin name is Channa (marulius, micropeltes, lucius, striata,
>> gachua). That sounds pretty good! Reminds me of Chana Masala.
>> Picture here:
>>
>> http://www.pattayafishing.com/freshwater.html
>>
>
> Ugh, I hate that site. I've seen it before.....the picture of the Giant
> Mekong Catfish bugs the hell out of me. Those are incredibly old,
> incredibly rare and incredibly at-risk fish, and its a crime that
> Pattaya Fishing advertises that they will take you fishing for them.
>
> That picture is of the largest freshwater fish ever caught and
> recorded. Here's a story about the efforts to save these fish:
> http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/05/0515_030515_giantcatfish
> .html
The caption said that it was the largest *scaleless" fish and claims they
grow to 650 pounds and 10' long. The white sturgeon, according to several
sites can grow to 1500 pounds and 20' long and are technically scaleless.
They are also endangered.
|
| | | | | | | | | | |
Date: 05 Nov 2006 10:05:10
From: riverman
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
"John Fereira" <jaf30@cornell.edu > wrote in message
news:Xns9871A982BC2D4jaf30cornelledu@24.24.2.166...
> "riverman" <nospam@sorry.com> wrote in news:454b422c$1@127.0.0.1:
>
>>
>> "Bill Tuthill" <ccreekin@yahoo.com> wrote in message
>> news:454aa172@news.meer.net...
>>> Pete Cresswell <x@y.invalid> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Per riverman:
>>>>>In fact, the solution to the snakehead and carp invasion in the US
>>>>>might be to start advertising them as a game fish, and start putting
>>>>>them on menus. Look what it did for tuna, cod and lobster. :-)
>>>>
>>>> First thing, somebody's got to come up with a sweeter-sounding name
>>>> than "snakehead"..... -)
>>>
>>> The Latin name is Channa (marulius, micropeltes, lucius, striata,
>>> gachua). That sounds pretty good! Reminds me of Chana Masala.
>>> Picture here:
>>>
>>> http://www.pattayafishing.com/freshwater.html
>>>
>>
>> Ugh, I hate that site. I've seen it before.....the picture of the Giant
>> Mekong Catfish bugs the hell out of me. Those are incredibly old,
>> incredibly rare and incredibly at-risk fish, and its a crime that
>> Pattaya Fishing advertises that they will take you fishing for them.
>>
>> That picture is of the largest freshwater fish ever caught and
>> recorded. Here's a story about the efforts to save these fish:
>> http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/05/0515_030515_giantcatfish
>> .html
>
> The caption said that it was the largest *scaleless" fish and claims they
> grow to 650 pounds and 10' long. The white sturgeon, according to several
> sites can grow to 1500 pounds and 20' long and are technically scaleless.
> They are also endangered.
Well, then its only a matter of time until Pattaya Fishing starts outfitting
trips for them.
Interesting that they claim that the fish caught in northern Thailand might
have been the largest freshwater fish ever caught, as this site
http://www.fws.gov/Endangered/features/sturgeon/index.html claims that a
1500 pound white sturgeon was caught in 1898. Maybe it has something to do
with recordkeeping?
--riverman
|
| |
Date: 31 Oct 2006 09:36:23
From: Wm Watt
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
If it's motors that disturb these fish perhaps boaters will go back to
paddles, oars, and sails.
Every cloud, as they say, has it's silver lining.
|
| |
Date: 29 Oct 2006 00:54:02
From: Tracy C
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Saw this on the news - was unbelievable! The fish were jumping all over the
place - some folks got hit in the face, with at least one person getting a
broken nose. Lots of people wore goggles to protect their eyes. Couldn't
believe what I was seeing! As soon as they started the boats, fish were
jumping everywhere. Was fun to watch.
"Garrison Hilliard" <garrison@efn.org > wrote in message
news:qnmqj2hbc53me2ug0r0kgdhuiqbn20ennr@4ax.com...
> You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
>
> From staff and wire reports
>
>
>
>
> Associated Press
>
> Silver carp, like this one in the Missouri River, were brought to the
> United
> States from Asia about 30 years ago.
>
> ST. LOUIS - For years, boaters and fishermen on many midwestern rivers
> have
> battled a fish with a bizarre behavior: silver carp that launch themselves
> into
> the air, jumping into boats and often slapping the unsuspecting upside the
> head.
>
> "They can break your nose or knock you out of the boat," said Duane
> Chapman, a
> fisheries biologist with the U.S. Geological Survey.
>
> The carp, brought to the United States from Asia by private fish farmers
> 30
> years ago, are more than a nuisance to people. They and their non-jumping
> relative, the bighead carp, compete with native fish for food such as
> paddlefish, bigmouth buffalo and gizzard shad.
>
> They have established themselves in parts of the Missouri, Mississippi,
> Ohio and
> Illinois rivers.
>
> Silver carp are rare in the Cincinnati area of the Ohio River, according
> to
> biologists with the Ohio River Valley Water Sanitation Commission.
>
> "They're pretty abundant in the lower part of the river around Paducah,
> but
> they're not common up here," said biologist Jeff Thomas. "We did see one
> last
> year around the Markland Dam. Other than that, I haven't heard any reports
> of
> them around Cincinnati."
>
> However, that could change in a few years.
>
> "They seem to be gradually working their way upstream," said Thomas. "If
> water
> conditions are right for them up here, we may see them in a couple of
> years."
>
> Thomas said the river temperature is cooler and the water is clearer in
> the
> Cincinnati area than it is down river.
>
> "We're not really sure which factors are most critical for silver carp,"
> said
> Erich Emery, another ORSANCO biologist. "Only time will tell if the
> conditions
> here are conducive to them. They do seem to like to breed in sluggish,
> backwater
> areas and there are more of those areas down river than here."
>
> There's little profit for commercial fishermen in harvesting the fish. But
> the
> St. Louis Zoo may be the answer to that dilemma.
>
> Rob Hayward, a University of Missouri-Columbia fisheries researcher, and
> Chapman
> are part of a team of researchers seeking to create a carp product to feed
> to
> zoo animals.
>
> "We want to make good food of bad fish," said Ellen Dierenfeld, staff
> nutritionist at the zoo.
>
> The zoo, one of the nation's largest, annually purchases as feed more than
> 60
> tons of fish - mostly marine species such as mackerel, herring and
> capelin.
> Prices range from 30 cents to 70 cents per pound, and zoo officials
> believe they
> could save money by feeding the carp to animals.
>
> Dierenfeld believes up to 25 percent of the fish feed could be replaced
> with
> carp.
>
> "This would help reduce pressures on marine fisheries and help solve the
> Asian
> carp problem," she said.
>
> And if the more than 200 accredited U.S. zoos did likewise, commercial
> fishermen
> would have a reason to harvest the nuisance fish.
>
> University of Missouri-Columbia food scientist Andrew Clarke has developed
> a
> "carp cake" made from raw, ground fish, a process that allows different
> size
> feed for different animals. Dierenfeld said vitamins and mineral
> supplements
> could be added to the carp cake.
>
> Dierenfeld hopes to begin a pilot feeding study with penguins, sea lions
> and
> pelicans by next spring. Other zoos may also participate, she said.
>
> The Cincinnati Zoo is not currently a candidate for the program.
>
> "We've heard of it, but we have no plans for it at this time," said
> Cincinnati
> Zoo spokeswoman Barbara Risch..
>
> Asian carp were imported in the 1970s as a way to control algae and
> plankton in
> fish ponds. But during the floods of 1993 and 1995, the fish made their
> way into
> the wild.
>
> It is believed the silver carp jump out of the water as a flight response
> when
> disturbed - possibly by the sound of boat motors.
>
> The high-jumping fish can be so dangerous that Missouri Department of
> Conservation staff wear head gear for protection while motoring on
> fast-moving
> boats. Some state boats have protective netting around the driver area and
> across the bow.
>
> The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service last month published a proposed rule to
> ban
> the import and interstate transport of silver carp.
>
>
>
> Publication date: 10-23-2006
>
> http://news.cincypost.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20061023/NEWS01/610230363
|
| |
Date: 23 Oct 2006 22:01:30
From: Rodney Long
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
Garrison Hilliard wrote:
> You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
>
> From staff and wire reports
>
>
>
>
> Associated Press
>
> Silver carp, like this one in the Missouri River, were brought to the United
> States from Asia about 30 years ago.
>
> ST. LOUIS - For years, boaters and fishermen on many midwestern rivers have
> battled a fish with a bizarre behavior: silver carp that launch themselves into
> the air, jumping into boats and often slapping the unsuspecting upside the head.
>
Man I bet it would be a blast, to "blast" those things,, put someone in
the front of the boat with a shotgun, it would be like trap shooting on
the fly. But I bet it would not be legal in any state,, too bad, it
could really reduce their numbers
--
Rodney Long,
Inventor of the Mojo SpecTastic "WIGGLE" rig, SpecTastic Thread,
Boomerang Fishing Pro. ,Stand Out Hooks ,Stand Out Lures,
Mojo's Rock Hopper & Rig Saver weights, and the EZKnot
http://www.ezknot.com
|
| | |
Date: 06 Dec 2007 19:29:05
From: Lu Powell
Subject: Re: You've got to be kidding, leaping carp?
|
The makings of a new extreme sport. See the video at:
http://loserswithsocks.com/2007/05/24/bowfishing-you-gotta-to-see-this/
"Rodney Long" <rdlong@charter.net > wrote in message
news:lmf%g.21$TI2.3@newsfe04.lga...
> Garrison Hilliard wrote:
>> You've got to be kidding, leaping carp? From staff and wire reports
>>
>>
>> Associated Press
>> Silver carp, like this one in the Missouri River, were brought to
>> the United
>> States from Asia about 30 years ago.
>>
>> ST. LOUIS - For years, boaters and fishermen on many midwestern
>> rivers have
>> battled a fish with a bizarre behavior: silver carp that launch
>> themselves into
>> the air, jumping into boats and often slapping the unsuspecting
>> upside the head.
>>
>
>
> Man I bet it would be a blast, to "blast" those things,, put someone
> in the front of the boat with a shotgun, it would be like trap
> shooting on the fly. But I bet it would not be legal in any state,,
> too bad, it could really reduce their numbers
> --
> Rodney Long,
> Inventor of the Mojo SpecTastic "WIGGLE" rig, SpecTastic Thread,
> Boomerang Fishing Pro. ,Stand Out Hooks ,Stand Out Lures,
> Mojo's Rock Hopper & Rig Saver weights, and the EZKnot
> http://www.ezknot.com
|
|
